Suing A Florida HOA or COA for Fiduciary Duty Failures

Is suing a Florida HOA an option? Homeownership in Florida’s gated communities and condominium complexes often comes with the added responsibility of being a part of a homeowners association (HOA) or condominium owners association (COA). While these associations are established to maintain and enhance property values, there are instances when homeowners believe their HOA or COA has failed in its fiduciary duties, necessitating legal action. Florida homeowners can explore how they can address such concerns, understanding that the process can be intricate and requires careful consideration by a lawyer.

Understanding Dispute Resolution Requirements

Florida law generally requires condo owners (under Florida Statutes 718.1255) and homeowners (under Florida Statutes 720.311) to attempt dispute resolution through non-binding arbitration and mediation, respectively, before pursuing legal action against their associations. However, exceptions apply, particularly in cases involving allegations of fiduciary duty breaches by the board or individual board members.

When the heart of the claim revolves around the failure of the HOA or COA board to perform its fiduciary duties, exceptions typically apply to the mandatory dispute resolution processes. This means that homeowners can generally proceed directly with legal action in these specific cases.

Legal Actions Against the HOA or Board Members

In cases involving fiduciary duty breaches, homeowners have options. They can take legal action against the HOA itself, seeking remedies such as injunctive relief or monetary damages to address the alleged failures.

Alternatively, homeowners can pursue legal action against individual members of the board who are believed to have breached their fiduciary obligations. This can include claims for negligence, mismanagement of association funds, or other related misconduct.

Homeowners considering which of these two strategies to implement typically would benefit from consulting experienced legal counsel.  A legal counsel with experience managing HOA and COA dispute cases would be able to determine which strategy better fits the particular circumstances of the case. 

Complex Nature of Fiduciary Duties

Defining an association’s fiduciary duties is complex, often involving adherence to multiple layers of legal documents, including the association’s Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&R), bylaws, local ordinances, Florida statutes, and even federal laws.

These duties typically encompass financial management, maintenance of common areas, enforcing community rules, and acting in the best interests of homeowners.

“Homeowners considering which of these two strategies to implement typically would benefit from consulting experienced legal counsel.”

The Importance of Legal Counsel

Given the intricate nature of HOA and COA law in Florida, homeowners considering legal action should seek the advice of an experienced Florida attorney well-versed in the nuances of association law.

An attorney can help you navigate the complexities of your case, ensure compliance with relevant laws, assess the strength of your claim, and guide you through the legal process.

In conclusion, homeowners facing fiduciary duty failures by their Florida HOA or COA have legal options available to address these concerns. Understanding the exceptions to mandatory dispute resolution requirements, the potential legal actions against the association or board members, and the intricacies of fiduciary duties is vital. However, due to the complex nature of these cases, consulting with a knowledgeable Florida attorney is strongly advised. Their expertise can be invaluable in advocating for your rights and achieving a resolution that aligns with your best interests as a homeowner.

South Florida Law

Attempting to sue your association or its leadership can be complex, so it is important to have an experienced HOA/COA attorney on your side. At South Florida Law, we have represented clients in a wide range of HOA and COA disputes, and we can help you navigate the process. 

Contact us today to schedule a consultation either via our contact form or by calling (954) 900-8885.

Similar Posts